
Marie’s Column in the Scottish Sun | Tuesday 17th November 2027
THE Scottish Greens are not in government, but they clearly still have an influential voice from the sidelines. I’ve got friends in every party, but the Scottish Green Party has completely changed – it is not the party it was 10 years ago.
This is a Green Party that believes in independence but can’t raise enough funds in Scotland so relies on Zack Polanski to support them.This, despite the fact they cry wolf at other political parties in relation to how they get their donations.
But my main gripe with the Greens isn’t their hypocrisy when it comes to party funding – it’s that they’re not living in the real world. They are out of touch with reality in our communities. They don’t appreciate how difficult it is right now for so many people to keep a job down, feed your kids, pay your mortgage and run a car.
The Scottish Greens are good at preaching what I call “kid-on communism” – that’s to say, not the real thing but a brand of politics to suit certain individuals while not doing things that make life better for ordinary people.
Of course, it’s up to John Swinney and his government how far they take it with the Green Party after their power-sharing deal collapsed in 2024 when Humza Yousaf was FM. But that coalition with the SNP saw the Greens play their part in cutting around £200 million from the housing budget in the face of a housing emergency.
That shows just how detached they are from some of the most pressing issues facing the country. John Swinney is short of a Scottish Parliament majority after May’s Holyrood election. But he would be well advised to steer clear of any pact with the Greens and instead continue to run a minority administration doing deals with different opposition parties on an issue-by-issue basis.
That’s the way it should be. I learned the importance of trying to take points on board from all sides of a debate from my dad. He was a trade unionist and he brought us up to believe that you need to listen to all views across the political spectrum, because that’s what builds a nation. The biggest failure would be if John Swinney elects to go in deeper with the Greens to start getting budgets passed at Holyrood.
Another thing I strongly disagree with the Greens on is their stance on allowing foreign nationals with only temporary permission to stay in the UK to stand in Scottish elections.
I was pleased to see a Holyrood committee recently say that those rules should be reconsidered. That’s especially so when we have a Scottish Youth Parliament for 12 to 25 year-olds.
These are great young people – I work with a lot of them. And it should be those young people at the front of that queue, being put forward for election as MSPs by political parties.
What are we actually saying here? That we don’t have people good enough in Scotland to stand for any political party? Of course not. However, the issues facing us as a country go far beyond the question of the influence of the Greens on policies.
But, despite the many challenges, I’m still positive about the future. I’ve worked in the City of London as a young woman, come through Black Wednesday in 1992 and the housing crisis in 2008, amongst many other setbacks. And there’s one thing about Scots – we’re resilient. However, what we need from both the Scottish and UK Governments are policies to boost growth and drive enterprise.
There are actually fewer proactive policies on that front on a UK-wide level from the Westminster Government than we had 20 years ago. Here in Scotland, we need to be a nation of Bravehearts who are going to fight to grow our economy.
The business sector is always up for that fight. But we certainly shouldn’t be sitting here an oil-rich country debating whether we should be opening oil fields or not. That is just outrageous. For me, the Rosebank oil field should be opened and we should be pushing and encouraging entrepreneurship at every turn.
In order to have a social welfare system fit for purpose, you need entrepreneurs and businesspeople to pay into the system to drive bottom-up growth, so that we can pay wages and fund key services. If there’s anything that’s wrong with both governments just now, it’s that they are not doing enough to recognise the good work that is being done by the private sector.
So if politicians in Edinburgh and London truly want to see a successful country they need to do far more to encourage wealth-creation and boost jobs. That includes making the most of all our natural resources – and not pandering to the “kid-on communism” of the Greens.
Read Marie’s article on The Scottish Sun website.